Welcome to Old John's Luncheonette
Old John's Luncheonette, located at 148 W 67th St in New York, combines classic diner charm with modern flair. This stylish eatery offers a range of mouthwatering dishes, from gooey mozzarella sticks to delicious buttermilk pancakes, each showcasing fresh ingredients and hearty flavors. The standout items like their cheddar waffle and black-and-white milkshake evoke nostalgia while providing a trendy twist. Patrons rave about the friendly service, making it a welcoming spot for both locals and newcomers. Expect a vibrant atmosphere, delectable comfort food, and a commitment to quality that makes every meal memorable at Old John’s.
-
148 W 67th St, New York, NY 10023, United States148 W 67th St, New York, NY 10023, United States Hotline: +1 212-874-2700
Welcome to Old John’s Luncheonette, a delightful culinary gem nestled at 148 W 67th St, New York, NY. This quaint spot perfectly marries modern chic with classic diner charm, offering a welcoming atmosphere that makes it ideal for both locals and visitors. With a phone number to reach them at +1 212-874-2700, you’ll find that connecting with Old John’s is just as easy as enjoying the charm and comfort that the restaurant effortlessly exudes.
At Old John’s Luncheonette, the menu is a testament to culinary creativity and fresh ingredients. The standout dish, the Blackened Fish Sandwich made with Icelandic cod and served on a fluffy brioche roll, tempts the palate with its homemade tartar sauce and crisp lettuce. Dining here is a feast for the senses; the Tuna Melt is another must-try, boasting a blend of flavorful tuna salad and creamy New York State cheddar on sourdough bread, all for just $15.00. With dishes like the Turkey Club, which comes loaded with roasted turkey, guacamole, and chipotle mayo on ciabatta, you are truly in for a treat as you savor the upscale twist on beloved classics.
For those seeking a healthy start to the day, Old John's offers dishes that are both nourishing and delicious. The Granola & Yogurt served with fresh berries is a perfect choice for morning brunchers or a light afternoon snack, while the Oatmeal, either with or without fruit, offers comfort and warmth, ideal for the chilly New York mornings.
The breakfast and brunch selections are equally impressive, featuring decadent options like the Stuffed French Toast, which delights with creamy mascarpone and a luscious caramel sauce. The buttermilk pancakes, fluffy and golden, are a satisfying choice for those looking to indulge.
Patrons rave about the experience at Old John’s. From Sinead McAleer’s praise of their exceptional mezcal negroni, to Rasheeda Eskak’s admiration for the friendly staff and trendy decor, the reviews paint a vivid picture of this bustling restaurant. Customers also appreciate the generous portions and the modern touch of classic diner elements, such as black and white malt milkshakes, adding nostalgia to the dining experience.
In a city where dining options abound, Old John’s Luncheonette stands out not only for its menu but for the friendly vibe and welcoming service. Whether you are stopping by for a quick takeout sandwich, sharing a meal with friends, or discovering a new favorite breakfast spot, Old John’s offers something for everyone. Be sure to visit, but remember to consider reservations as popularity has a way of filling up tables quickly!
Very modern, clean restaurant with classy hints and nods to the classic diner style. The Greek salad had fun, crunchy little chickpeas. Their mezcal negroni was exceptional - would order again! Overall, loved the service and great place to bring people who are new to the city!
My husband and I love this place! Food is fresh and delicious. Not to mention abundant. I love the coat rack at every booth.
Old school place, with upscale trendy touches! They have black and white malt milkshakes oh my god, I never thought I’d see one in the city! Standard breakfast fare is available along with some fresh new options! The service is friendly, and I love how the staff gets along, it really hammers home that the place is well run! Food is so delicious, I was swooning over my cheddar waffle! May be a bit of wait time but it’s so worth it!
Great tuna melt, soup and French fries. Looks amazing with classic diner decorations but not worn out. Had trouble getting the check at a shift change or something but otherwise great service despite it being busy. Friendly staff. Great value compared to Viand or Utopia diners as well.
We did not have reservations but got seated nonetheless, although there was a queue when we left. I would recommend reserving first! Food was divine, exactly what we needed on a cold winter morning. Great service, friendly staff. A new favourite spot for us.
This is a cozy diner always bustling with local residents. If you're unlucky, you might have to wait 20-30 minutes for a table. Overall, the food is delicious, and despite the busy atmosphere, the staff is remarkably friendly. Portions are quite large, so overordering might lead to regret. However, make sure to save room for dessert—banana pudding and carrot cake are highly recommended and absolutely delightful!
First visit to this gorgeous little NYC diner. Welcomed warmly and efficiently. Do recommend booking as people were turned away. Started with the matzo ball soup and special of the crab cake. Both delicious. Then had short rib cooked beautifully and meatloaf, also excellent. These meals felt and tasted homemade. Waiting staff very nice. Highly recommend.
This place is a wonderful diner! Old John's Luncheonette on the UWS serves a great selection of delicious soups , sandwiches , breakfast dishes , drinks , and more! Definitely get the Crispy Chicken Sandwich with a cup of Chicken Noodle Soup! Staff is friendly and professional and the service is quick. Ambience is great and the place is beautifully decorated! I wish I knew about this place sooner!